I'd rather see the bag of doo-doo than the piles that are ignored by people

For me, it depends. In a maintained park, yes--some park worker will pick up the "forgotten" bag. Several miles out into the woods on a hike? I'd rather see the poo--at least it will be broken down quickly. Those bags last forever.

Those bags last forever.

Actually, some of them are biodegradable. Plastics can be made of non-petroleum sources and most of those are biodegradable. Look up polylactic acid. I couldn't find out quickly how soon it will break down.

I can top that...we found a box once with poop inside the box, on top of the logbook and stamp. And while checking on one of our boxes, we found it full of pee. What a treat:-(

Actually, some of them are biodegradable.

Doesn't make it excusable. Dog doo is natural fertilizer, while plastic bags are litter.

Dog doo is natural fertilizer, while plastic bags are litter.

True. On one of my geocaching trips, on my way out, I saw such a blue bag of dog poo that someone had left by the side of the trail. I picked it up to throw it away. Since there was no trash can at this particular trailhead, I had to take it all of the way home in my car, in the trunk. I tossed it as soon as I got home.

If they're not going to take it (the dog poo) along with them they should at least get it off of the trail.

a plastic bag of dog doo

At least it was still in the plastic bag. I found an unpublished geocache once near one of our letterbox hybrids. Left it and checked on it a couple of months later to see if it was still there. It was. But this time someone pooped in it - a big dump. Then they lifted the container and placed it in the chest high nook (unless the somehow managed to squat up in that tree =| ). Weird compulsion.

If they're not going to take it (the dog poo) along with them they should at least get it off of the trail.

I agree. There's a trail at the back of my house that gets quite a bit of poo during the winter (not too bad during the warmer weather). But once a winter we usually get a thaw. I'll go out with my shovel and toss what I see off the trail. In late April (the worst time for winter left overs on the trail), I carry a cedar shingle to toss the stuff into the forest. I love dogs and don't want to see them get into trouble and have fewer areas to exercise and enjoy nature.

This is why we need an "Ick!" button.