Since I don't have that on my menu, I assume it's a premium member only thing.

Really? It didn't used to be premium only.... look here? (not a seperate menu.. just look near bottom of page)

http://www.atlasquest.com/mypage/stats/

Really? It didn't used to be premium only.... look here? (not a seperate (sic) menu.. just look near bottom of page)

You're seeing it because you are a premium member.

The rest of us see:

My Statistics
You must be a premium member to view your statistics.