You said you were not sure what to do with the series that is partially missing, but now has a blue diamond. If the log book is still there, I would only retire the missing ones. We decided to retire our series because the box with the log book is now missing.

We just lost a box and I was PO'd. So much work goes into them

I agreed with you 100 percent. A lot of work goes into a box as well as a handmade crochet Boxing Buddy. A person really can get PO'd when they think about the host not sending their Shirley Temple BB back.
A year has almost come and gone since you received Shirley Temple.
What did you do with her?